14 Comments
User's avatar
Chris Patten's avatar

Perfect analogy and I say that as an omnivore who knows that there is no moral argument for my behaviour!

Expand full comment
Anne Liddell's avatar

Probably not the point but the pic of the hands holding the flaccid sea cucumber made me feel sick 🤢

Expand full comment
Maria Andrea's avatar

What if the sea cucumber thinks it’s a cucumber? 😏

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

A sea cucumber isn't a cucumber tho. :D

Expand full comment
Maria Andrea's avatar

I agree but you try telling the sea cucumber that! 😆

Expand full comment
Sarah Macnaughton's avatar

I love this so much. I worked with 'sea cucumber ranchers' in the Philippines... Turns out sea cucumbers can be be 'farmed' and looked after properly, but most sea cucumbers are very much exploited in horrible conditions. (am aware I am being much too literal here). Just an interesting side note.

Expand full comment
Francesca's avatar

I’m not vegan , but I do feel your pain. However it’s vegetarians who buy all those over processed “meat” substitutes and claim they are better for the planet than meat. There have been vegetarians for decades managing without them. What is the carbon footprint like on these products? I doubt it’s lower than “farm fresh” local meat.

Expand full comment
Liz May's avatar

Love your analogy. Have a great Christmas. X

Expand full comment
Lesley's avatar

Brilliant analogy. Also sea cucumbers are used in fake medicines.

Expand full comment
Fran's avatar

Thank dog for this! As a vegan it's great to see something that isn't "a joke" said about vegans. Looking forward to your next piece.

Expand full comment
Marianne's avatar

They are all bloody mental.glad you don’t eat or use animal products .I can’t bear the terrible suffering inflicted on animals so

in my own small way don’t do it.

Expand full comment
Lindsay Garrett's avatar

"Words mean something. And it isn’t ‘snobby’ to point this out."

((:

Expand full comment
Lyndsay Vaughan's avatar

Also you could point out that the Pearl Fish actually likes to swim into the Sea Cucumbers butt to live - it’s safe, it can feed, & must be pretty cosy!

It’s a creature & creature relationship rather than a creature & vegetable relationship!

Expand full comment
William Braden: mental notes's avatar

"Virtue is its own reward." So being a vegan is its own reward -- there don't seem to be other rewards! Pointing out other people's inconsistencies, or stupidities, or prejudices, is an enormous task. And does it have rewards? Do the inconsistent, or stupid, or prejudiced, hearing the gentle criticism, see the Light, like Saul on the road to Damascus? I guess maybe once in a while....

Expand full comment